“Green Bags”-Do they Work?
May 15th, 2008A client of mine recently asked me about an infomercial on a product by Debbie Meyer’s known as “Green Bags”. They wanted to know if they actually work. A recent feature on our local news tested these bags and reported positive findings. I decided to do a little research to give a general review and opinion of my findings. Note that this review comes with no actual product testing on my part.
Manufacturer claims
The product purportedly slows down the ripening process by removing ethylene gas produced from fruits, vegetables and flowers. The bag is lined with minerals that absorb ethylene, ammonia and CO2 and control humidity and moisture. The bags can be re-used 8 to 10 times and food must be stored dry. The running price is $9.95 for 10 small and 10 large bags plus shipping and handling.
Consumer opinions
After scouring community forums the basic consensus was 50/50-positive and negative. Positive comments supported all of the manufacturer’s claims; although, there was a general problem with bananas. Many of the negative comments were that they did not work, were smaller than expected, and easily torn. Several consumers reported extremely high shipping costs of about $40.
My opinion
Personally I feel these bags are a big waste of money. “Green Bags” are literally that—green in color, not environmentally green. Remember, they are still plastic bags.
Cost
First, the bags are very expensive and can only be used 8-10 times. After that they are to be used as a general produce bag. The claims on expensive shipping are most likely true. Usually the cheaper the product, the more expensive the shipping; it increases the seller’s profits.
Ethylene Absorption
A study from 1995 was conducted to test the absorption ability of ethylene with three minerals, activated carbon-impregnated paper, and fly ash. The actual minerals were not disclosed but reportedly those mined in Arizona—same as those used in Green Bags. Using sand (doesn’t absorb ethylene) and Purafil (does absorb ethylene) as controls, ethylene was injected in jars with concentrations of ethylene being tested at intervals. The results: the three mineral materials tested absorbed NO ethylene.
Although you can never conclude something from just one study, it does give evidence towards a useless product. My assumption is that the mineral lining includes one of the ‘ites’ such as bentonite. Read the Report.
Conclusion
Make your own decision as to purchase this product. There are several useful tips to storing produce that will do the same thing as these bags and not cost you a fortune.
Lettuce-Cut up single lettuce leaves. Take a fresh paper towel roll and place one piece of lettuce, fold, then another leaf, fold, etc.. Place in a plastic bag and keep in the fridge. It will last you a month.
Mushrooms-Slice mushrooms and place on a paper bag. Cover with a paper bag and place another set of mushrooms on top, repeat. Place in the fridge sealed in bag or not.
Tomatoes-Keep on the counter, not in the fridge.
Limes-Keep sealed in plastic bag in the fridge.
Fresh herbs-Keep in a vase with water in the fridge or freeze.
Chris Theberge, RD, LDN
The Nutrition and Food Web Archive






